Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robbie Marriage's avatar

I don't know man. Do you think this contract is a good idea? I suppose it depends on how valuable you think roster spots are, because the Yankees have already exceeded Juan's WAR from last season with their additions, and those additions do not add up to $765M. Especially looking at Juan's fielding and baserunning numbers, which are going down and down and down, meaning he's going to have to spend most of this contract as a DH.

That's fine, but unless they're literally the best hitter in baseball, DHs do not win MVPs. They are not the best player on championship teams. You need a lot of support around a DH to win with one, or another star player that's even better. Think Manny Ramirez being the real star on the teams that David Ortiz gets credit for. With all this being known, do you think it's a good idea to give $700M and more to a DH? He won't be one immediately, but for most of the contract he will be, and to me it seems like a really big stretch to give that much money (and therefore commitment) to such a player.

I'm glad this race got too rich for my Blue Jays. This feels like a contract that has a high chance of killing what could've been a great era for the Mets, if even the slightest thing goes wrong. I don't think the loss of Soto will hurt the Yankees very much at all, and I think I'm going to believe the Red Sox being in on a big money player when I see it. They're not fooling anybody. This race was NY vs NY, and I'm not sure which side won it. The Mets got the best player, but the Yankees used their money to bring in more 2023 WAR.

I guess we'll see.

Expand full comment
BirdlandFeed (Ben)'s avatar

Congrats New York Mest!

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts